New York Times: “Palestinians are not a people”

Did the New York Times really say the Palestinians are not a people? Well, no, and, of course, never.

But one week after world leaders condemned the Turkish prime minister for calling Zionism a crime against humanity, the Times apparently had no trouble giving coveted space from its online Opinion page to a manifesto by an unknown college teacher arguing that Israel has no right to exist, and that the very idea of a Jewish people — “scattered across the globe, speaking many different languages and defined largely by religion” — present a “difficult case.”

We had thought the League of Nations and the United Nations long ago settled this question within the tribunals of international law. But apparently not for Amhert professor Joseph Levine, nor for the New York Times.

Levine takes it as a given that the Palestinian Arabs have a natural claim to the same right of self-determination that he is so quick to deny to Israel and Jewish people. Indeed he argues that the very idea of Israel as a Jewish state “is in fact a violation of the right to self-determination” of its Palestinian inhabitants. (By the way, the UN resolution of 29 November 1947 embracing the creation of a “Jewish state” mentions that term no less than 30 times.)

The poorly argued article is replete with other such glaring self-contradictions, is poorly written, and offers so little of value in originality, creativity or timeliness, that one has to wonder why the world’s top newspaper decided to publish it.

In other writings, Levine’s bitter hatred for Israel and his native-born Judaism are more overtly stated:

Let’s be clear what founding the Jewish State of Israel involved, and continues to involve. We came into another people’s land — admittedly, after enduring centuries of oppression ourselves — kicked them out brutally, and treated those who remained like dirt. We continue to oppress Palestinians horribly, and shamelessly exploit our own history of oppression and guilt-trip the rest of the world into letting us get away with it. This is how God’s people act? Not any God I wanted to have anything to do with.

5 Responses to “New York Times: “Palestinians are not a people””


  • Beverly Chabinsky

    It is for publishing garbage like this, that some years ago, my husband and I dropped our subscription to the NY Times and have never resubscribed. It has become a biased newspaper proven many times by UN Watch and Honest Reporting to mislead its readers and wallow in sensationalism that is not based on fact and is in fact totally fabricated. The “gray lady” deserves no respect!

  • Why doesn’t anyone notice that whenever people talk about Israel’s oppression of the Palestinians, they never bother to use actual concrete examples.

  • I wish it was a crime with punishment to publish racism, lies, dubious rumors and hate speech. I don’t believe such things are freedom but actually anti-freedom. Its a display of sick people riddled and imprisoned with misinformation & illogical hatred pretending to be free. I don’t believe sticking to the truth to be censorship. Over and over I have heard the NY Times has become nothing but a propoganda rag yet so many people still read it.
    I am not religious or conservative but consider myself a Progressive American who knows the great importance of Israel as a symbol of Justice and realises the dangers quite well and share my knowlege whenever, wherever I can. I trust Israel to stand as strong as possible with Ethics and Integrity despite the impossible situation because we need you.

  • That is Pathological Behavior from New York Times

  • In WW2, the Times covered up the genocide the Nazis were committing against the Jews.
    The Times barely reported about it.
    When it came to the Babi Yar massacre in 1941 in Ukraine, the NY Times wrote that 30,000 Russians and Ukrainians were killed.
    The Times didn’t even mention that all the victims in Babi Yar were Jews.
    The NY Times opposed the U.S recognizing Israel in 48.
    The NY Times opposed Israel bombing Iraq’s nuclear facility in 81.
    Last November, Roger Cohen of the Times basically comes out and says Israel should do nothing while Hamas fires hundreds of rockets at Israeli civilians.
    Ari Lieberman totally destroys the lies of Roger Cohen.
    http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2012/11/roger_cohen_and_the_new_york_times_useful_idiots.html

Leave a Reply